W-2 Boxes 1, 3 and 5 measure wages under different federal tax rules, so they do not always match. A traditional 401(k) employee deferral can be absent from the federal wage figure yet still count toward Medicare and Social Security wages. Qualifying health benefits and the Social Security wage cap can create other differences. Compare the underlying wage categories; do not add these overlapping boxes to calculate income.

Reviewed November 14, 2026 · U.S. federal W-2 wage-box comparison using the 2026 IRS instructions. Fictional examples assume an ordinary covered employee, a qualifying health arrangement and valid retirement contributions. Special benefits, tips, ownership rules, exempt employment and state wages require separate analysis.

Seeing three wage amounts can make a correct W-2 look inconsistent. The useful question is which compensation each box includes, not which number is the “real” paycheck. This guide reads the boxes themselves. For a broader comparison with the final payroll statement, use the year-end pay-stub reconciliation guide.

Keep wage amounts separate from taxes withheld

Under the 2026 General Instructions for Forms W-2 and W-3, Box 1 reports taxable wages, tips and other compensation for federal income-tax purposes. Box 3 reports wages subject to employee Social Security tax, with Social Security tips reported separately in Box 7. Box 5 reports Medicare wages and tips.

Boxes 2, 4 and 6 are different: they report employee tax withheld. A wage figure describes the relevant tax base; a withholding figure describes tax collected. Subtracting Box 2 from Box 1 does not reconstruct annual take-home pay because other taxes, benefit contributions and payment adjustments may also exist.

Pair each wage figure with the corresponding withholding field
Wage fieldWhat it describesWithholding field
Box 1Federal taxable wages, tips and other compensationBox 2: federal income tax withheld
Box 3, plus Box 7 where applicableSocial Security wages and separately reported Social Security tipsBox 4: Social Security tax withheld
Box 5Medicare wages and tipsBox 6: Medicare tax withheld, including applicable Additional Medicare Tax

The three wage fields can describe much of the same underlying compensation. An employee with $48,000 in both Boxes 3 and 5 did not receive $96,000 merely because those two entries match. Likewise, a lower Box 1 does not automatically mean that the employer paid less cash.

Traditional and Roth elections are an important difference

The IRS explanation of 401(k) plans states that traditional employee elective deferrals generally are excluded from current federal income-tax withholding and Box 1 wages, but remain subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes. That is one common reason Box 1 is lower than Boxes 3 and 5.

Designated Roth employee contributions do not receive that same current federal wage exclusion. The IRS retirement-contribution comparison identifies the different treatment and the related W-2 reporting. The actual plan type and contribution category matter; “retirement” alone is not a complete tax classification.

Look at your election and the applicable Box 12 code. Do not subtract a contribution again from Box 1 merely because Box 12 also lists it. For a traditional deferral already excluded from Box 1, repeating the subtraction would understate wages. Employer matching contributions also need their own treatment; they are not automatically employee salary deductions.

Original example: reconcile $50,000 across three boxes

Assume a fictional employee has $50,000 annual cash wages before employee benefit elections. The employee makes $2,000 of health salary reductions under an arrangement that qualifies for exclusion from federal income-tax, Social Security and Medicare wages. The employee also makes $3,000 of valid traditional 401(k) elective deferrals.

Assume all remaining wages are covered by Social Security and Medicare, there are no tips, taxable fringe benefits, corrections or other exclusions, and the wages are below the annual Social Security cap. This example is not for a more-than-2% S corporation shareholder or another special benefit situation.

Box 1 is $50,000 minus $2,000 minus $3,000, or $45,000. Boxes 3 and 5 each equal $50,000 minus $2,000, or $48,000. The $3,000 difference comes from the traditional deferral, which remains in these two employment-tax wage bases.

For fictional annual cash wages of 50000 dollars, 2000 dollars of qualifying health salary reduction and 3000 dollars of traditional 401(k) deferrals produce 45000 dollars in Box 1 and 48000 dollars in Boxes 3 and 5 under the stated assumptions.
The assumed qualified health reduction affects all three bases. The traditional retirement deferral affects Box 1 differently.

IRS Publication 15-B explains benefit exclusions and cafeteria-plan requirements, including exceptions. A payroll label such as “medical” does not establish that every premium qualifies or that every employee receives the same treatment. Verify the plan and employee circumstances before copying this calculation.

Now change only the retirement election: assume the $3,000 is a valid designated Roth 401(k) employee contribution. The health assumption stays the same. Box 1 becomes $48,000 because the Roth contribution remains in current taxable wages; Boxes 3 and 5 remain $48,000.

If the same 3000 dollar employee deferral is designated Roth rather than traditional, fictional Box1 rises from 45000 to 48000 dollars. Boxes 3 and 5 remain 48000 dollars; this does not calculate a 3000 dollar tax change.
A $3,000 difference in taxable wages is not a $3,000 difference in tax. The example does not choose a retirement strategy or calculate a return.

The example also does not calculate net pay. Benefit contributions reduce the cash available to the employee, and taxes have to be determined separately. Our gross versus net pay guide explains why taxable wages, gross earnings and the amount deposited should not be used interchangeably.

Why can Box 3 be lower than Box 5?

Social Security has an annual taxable wage limit; Medicare does not have the same wage cap. The 2026 W-2 instructions set the Social Security wage base at $184,500 and explain that Boxes 3 and 7 together cannot exceed that amount for the employer’s reporting. Box 5 can therefore exceed Box 3 when covered wages rise above the cap.

For a separate fictional 2026 employee with $191,000 of wages subject to both taxes before applying the Social Security limit, no tips and no other differences, Box 3 is $184,500 and Box 5 is $191,000. The $6,500 difference reflects this assumed cap effect. It is not an extra earnings payment or an unexplained deduction.

Do not transfer that 2026 cap into another year without checking that year’s official instructions. Also keep multiple employers separate: each employer’s form has its own reporting context. An employee’s annual return may need a separate excess-Social-Security-withholding review, rather than changing one employer’s wages to make all forms fit a single display.

Tips can make the simple Box 3 comparison incomplete because Social Security tips are recorded in Box 7. Special coverage and fringe-benefit rules may also create differences. The Social Security guide and Medicare guide address the separate payroll taxes and their limits.

Investigate the cause before requesting a correction

Gather the annual payroll summary, final statements, retirement elections, benefits records and any year-end adjustments. Confirm the employer and tax year first. Then prepare one bridge for each wage base. A gross-to-Box-1 bridge alone cannot establish the Social Security or Medicare result.

Ask payroll to identify which earning and benefit codes feed each box. If the difference is $3,000, do not assume it is retirement merely because your contribution was also $3,000. An amount match is a clue; the actual wage mapping supplies the explanation.

If the employer identifies an error, ask for its correction process and keep both the original and corrected documents. The IRS incorrect-W-2 guidance starts with contacting the employer. Our missing or incorrect W-2 guide explains the qualified substitute-form route if the issue remains unresolved; do not fabricate replacement wages to force matching boxes.

Use reconciled figures and the correct tax year

The Check Stubs Online W-2 builder is a document-preparation tool. At this review, its year selector offers 2025. Use it only for supported, authorized 2025 preparation; do not use that template for 2026 reporting. Reconcile all required fields against the issuer’s payroll records. A guide explaining 2026 rules does not establish that a tool supports every year or every special W-2 situation.

Do not choose the largest wage amount for every box or use a builder to overwrite an employer’s issued form. Preparing a PDF, furnishing it to an employee and filing with the government are separate actions. Follow the actual tool’s stated scope and the applicable official filing instructions.

Wage-box questions

Must Boxes 1, 3 and 5 match?

No. Retirement elections, benefit exclusions, the Social Security cap and other rules can produce legitimate differences.

Is Box 1 my take-home pay?

No. It is a federal taxable compensation amount, not the sum of your bank deposits after every deduction.

Do I add the three boxes together?

No. They overlap. Use each field for the purpose specified in the relevant form or application instructions.

Does Box 3 always equal Box 5 below the cap?

The simple example does, but tips, coverage and special rules can require a different comparison. Review the actual record.

The Check Stubs Online Editorial Team reviewed the 2026 W-2 instructions and federal benefit guidance, then independently verified the traditional, Roth and wage-cap examples.